Arle actually lost Carbuncle for three whole games. In Fever, she alone arrived at Primp Town without Carbuncle. Anxious without her companion, she used magic to conjure up an approximate replica of Carbuncle. The replica ran off and stumbled upon Raffine in her quest for the flying cane. Shortly before Fever 2, Arle found the replica and kept it with her closely. It was until 7, when Arle and Carbuncle were each sent to Ringo’s world, had they finally reunited.